Prison Pen Pals www.friendonline.org
  • About Friendonline
    • Helpful hints
  • USA
    • Oklahoma >
      • Emanuel Mitchell
      • James Mitchell
    • Louisiana
    • Florida >
      • Luis Caballero
      • Waldo Jeune
    • Texas >
      • Death Row >
        • A-B-C >
          • Alfred Brown
          • Allen Bridgers
          • Arturo Diaz
          • Beunka Adams
          • Beunka Adams
          • Carol Joe Parr
          • Carlos Ayestas
          • Carlos Trevino
          • Charles Don FLores
          • Christopher Wilkins
        • D-E-F >
          • Douglas Tyrone Armstrong
          • Duane Edward Buck
          • Elroy Chester
          • Fabian Hernandez
        • G-H-I >
          • Gary Green
          • Gerald Marshall
          • Guadalupe Esparza
          • Hector Medina
          • Humberto Garza
        • J-K-L >
          • James Broadnax
          • Juan Castillo
          • Jesse Joe Hernandez
          • Joe M. Luna
          • John Battalglia
          • John Allen Rubio
          • John M. Quintanilla >
            • The true story
          • John H. Ramirez
          • Joseph Gamboa
          • Juan Alvarez
          • Ker'Sean Ramey
          • LeJames Norman
        • M-N-O >
          • Manuel Velez
          • Milton Dwayne Gobert
          • Nelson Gongora
        • P-Q-R >
          • Pablo Melendez
          • Pablo Vasquez
          • Paul David Storey
          • Pete Russel
          • Preston Hughes >
            • The case
            • The case
          • Ramiro Ibarra
          • Ramiro Gonzalez
          • Raul Cortez
          • Ray Freeney
          • Robert Campbell
          • Ronald Hamilton
          • Ronnie Threadgill
          • Rosendo Rodriquez
          • Ricardo Vasquez
          • Ruben Gutierrez
        • S-T-U >
          • Santos Minjarez
          • Selwyn Davis
          • Stanley Griffin
          • Travis Runnels >
            • Reality Row
        • V-W-X >
          • Walter Sorto
          • Wesley Ruiz
          • William Rayford
        • Y-Z
      • Prison >
        • A-B-C >
          • Allan Bailey
          • Andrell Thompson
          • Andrew Sindt
          • Anthony Wiley
          • Bennie Price
          • Chad Davis >
            • Photos
            • Music
          • Charles Anthony Allen
          • Charlie Harris
          • Christopher Garcia
        • D-E-F >
          • Danny Dixon
          • Danny Spence
          • David Montanez
          • Doyal Garrett
          • Eliott Guerrero >
            • Poems
          • Emanuel Camacho Gomez
          • Fernando Puente
        • G-H-I >
          • Gerardo LLanas
          • Haywood Chambers
          • Irvan K. Beverly
          • Isaac Tamayo
        • J-K-L >
          • Jacob Sotello
          • James Michael Sepesi
          • Jeremiah D. Crow
          • Jerry Bradford
          • Jose Eloy Salazar
          • Joshua Paul De Leon
          • Julio Marcos
          • Kevin Cupples
          • Loerey Bernal
        • M-N-O >
          • Marcus Long
          • Mario Harris
          • Michael Betts
          • Michael Brown
          • Michael Montgomery
          • Odell Baker
        • P-Q-R >
          • Paul Polk
          • Phil Moss
          • Reid Whitesides
          • Robert Arambula
          • Robert Dudley
          • Robert McClure
          • Robert Torres
          • Roger Uvalle
          • Roosevelt Smith Jr.
        • S-T-U >
          • Travis Prunty
          • Tristan Williams
        • V-W-X
        • Y-Z
  • Zambia
    • Kabwe >
      • Joseph Sambwe Musonda
      • Justine Mumbi
      • Kennedy C. Chongo
  • The Netherlands
    • www.bonjo.nl
  • Contact
  • News updates
  • donations
  • Books

South Dakota House panel approves measure seeking limit on appeals by death-row inmates

2/15/2012

0 Comments

 
_South Dakota House panel approves measure seeking limit on appeals by death-row inmates


A South Dakota House committee endorsed a plan Wednesday aimed at preventing
death-row inmates from filing repeated appeals in an effort to delay their
executions.

Although the limits would apply to all serious criminal cases, Attorney General
Marty Jackley said the limits are especially needed in death penalty cases. 2
men convicted and sentenced to death two decades ago have avoided execution
because their appeals are still proceeding through the courts, he said.

Murder victims' families should not have to wait 20 years to see a death
sentence carried out, Jackley said.

"It doesn't end," Jackley said. "It's time to give a fair resolution, but a
timely resolution for victims."

People convicted of crimes in South Dakota can appeal their convictions to the
state Supreme Court.

Under the bill, convicts who lose a first direct appeal usually could file only
one secondary appeal. State law currently puts no limit on those secondary
appeals, called habeus corpus petitions. Those petitions generally argue that a
convict's constitutional rights were violated, and they often contend the
person's previous lawyers made mistakes.

The bill would limit convicts to one secondary appeal, unless new evidence is
discovered or an appeals court recognizes a new constitutional right that would
apply to the case. Those secondary appeals also would have to be filed within
two years of when the first direct appeal was decided or new evidence was
discovered.

"At some point, there needs to be finality. I would suggest this would give it
fair and reasonable finality," Jackley said.

The bill would apply to all people convicted of serious crimes, but South
Dakota Attorney General Marty Jackley says the limits are particularly needed
in cases where murderers have been sentenced to death.

The attorney general said the bill's limits on secondary appeals are the same
as those applied in 31 other states and the federal court system. If those
limits were in place in South Dakota, an execution could probably take place
within five to 10 years after a conviction, he said.

Ed and Peggy Schaeffer, whose son Donnivan was killed during a 1992 burglary of
a Rapid City doughnut shop, told lawmakers to adopt the changes. Peggy
Schaeffer said the man convicted and sentenced to death for her son's murder,
Charles Russell Rhines, is using secondary appeals to manipulate the judicial
system and delay his execution.

"It's almost as if Donnivan never existed," she said. "Well, he did. This is
why we are here today, waiting for justice."

Jackley also noted that Donald Moeller was sentenced to death for the 1990 rape
and killing of 9-year-old Becky O'Connell of Sioux Falls, but Moeller's appeals
continue.

"There has been no justice for the death of that 9-year-old girl," Jackley
said.

The House Judiciary Committee voted 10-3 to send the bill to the full House.

Rep. Mark Feinstein, D-Sioux Falls, voted against the bill, suggesting that the
state's legal costs would be lower if murderers were sentenced to life in
prison instead of death.

Supporters said the measure protects the rights of convicts but avoids
unnecessary repeated appeals.

"Families should not have to wait, and South Dakotans should not have to wait
for decades to see justice," said Rep. Stace Nelson, R-Fulton.

(source: Associated Press)
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012

    Categories

    All
    Abu Dhabi
    Alabama
    Alaska
    Amnesty International
    Arizona
    Arkansas
    Australia
    Bahrain
    Bangladesh
    Barbados
    Belarus
    Book
    Botswana
    California
    Canada
    China
    Colorado
    Connecticut
    Dakota
    Delaware
    Documentary
    Egypt
    Film
    Florida
    Gaza
    Georgia
    Ghana
    Global
    Guantanamo
    Guyana
    Human Rights Watch
    Idaho
    Illinois
    India
    Indiana
    Indonesia
    Iowa
    Iran
    Iraq
    Israel
    Jamaica
    Japan
    Kansas
    Keith Thurmond
    Kentucky
    Kuwait
    Lebanon
    Liberia
    Libya
    Louisiana
    Malaysia
    Maldives
    Maryland
    Massachusetts
    Mental Retardation
    Mexico
    Michican
    Military
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Missouri
    Montana
    Morocco
    Movie
    Nebraska
    Nevada
    New Jersey
    New Mexico
    New York
    New Zealand
    Nigeria
    North Carolina
    North Korea
    Norway
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Oregon
    Pakistan
    Pennsylvania
    Philippines
    Portugal
    Rhode Island
    Russia
    Saudi Arabia
    Singapore
    Sister Helen Prejean
    South Africa
    South Carolina
    South Dakota
    Sri Lanka
    Sudan
    Syria
    Taiwan
    Tanzania
    Television
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Thailand
    Theatre
    TRINIDAD & TOBAGO
    Tulsa
    Tunesia
    Uganda
    Ukraine
    United Arab Emirates
    United Kingdom
    Urgent Appeal
    Usa
    Us Military
    Utah
    Vietnam
    Virginia
    Washington
    World
    Wyoming
    Yemen
    Zimbabwe

    RSS Feed

Powered by
✕